Enter a roof size and a horizon to compare materials.
A like-for-like comparison of material longevity value, not a full budget: it excludes maintenance and repairs and does not adjust for inflation. Real installed prices vary by region, complexity, and contractor.
Compare over (years)
Roof type
Data sources
Installed prices are cross-checked 2026 trade figures and service life comes from the InterNACHI chart plus manufacturer guides. National prices are used for a like-for-like comparison, so results are not regionally adjusted.
Every roofing calculator
Sixteen tools for pricing, measuring, and planning a roof.
The comparison, explained
Every figure below comes from the same verified data the calculator runs on.
Comparing roofing materials by cost per year
The cheapest roof isn't the cheapest roof. On a 24-square roof, 3-tab asphalt installs for $10,800, the lowest sticker on the table. But at a typical 18-year life, that's $600 per year of service, and over 40 years you'd buy that roof three times. Clay tile installs for $34,800, more than triple the sticker, and at a typical 100-year life it costs $348 per year, the cheapest per year of anything here. That's the comparison this table runs for your roof size and time horizon: installed cost divided by typical life, with full re-roofs counted over the period you pick.
How to read the ranking honestly
Cost per year rewards materials you'll actually stay under. Selling in seven years? A century roof mostly benefits the next owner, and the sensible middle looks like exposed-fastener steel at $450 per year or architectural asphalt at $557. Forever house? The durable end of the table earns its premium year after year. Know the table's limits too: it deliberately excludes maintenance and repairs and doesn't adjust for inflation, so it's a clean like-for-like longevity comparison, not a full budget. Wood shake is the cautionary tale: $25,200 installed, a typical 30-year life, $840 per year, the priciest per year on the board, before its above-average upkeep is even counted.
Match the material to your horizon
Prices here are national averages. For a localized, itemized figure on any material, the roof cost calculator prices it for your ZIP, and the lifespan tool shows the full ranges behind the typical figures used in the math.
Frequently asked questions
What's the cheapest roofing material long term?
On this verified data, clay tile, at $348 per year of service thanks to a typical 100-year life. Among affordable options, exposed-fastener steel is the standout at $450 per year, beating every asphalt grade.
Is a steel roof cheaper than shingles in the long run?
Entry-level steel, yes. Exposed-fastener steel runs $450 per year of service against $557 for architectural asphalt and $600 for 3-tab. Premium metals cost more per year, like standing seam at $672 and copper at $706, and you're paying for other qualities alongside longevity.
Why does wood shake rank so expensive?
Cedar installs at $25,200 for 24 squares but typically lasts about 30 years. That works out to $840 per year, the highest on the table, before its above-average maintenance enters the picture.